Recently Watched: The Red Shoes (1948), West Side Story (1961), & Black Narcissus (1947)

220px-The_Red_Shoes_(1948_movie_poster)I. The Red Shoes [1948] – ★★★★1/2

The Red Shoes is about the rise to stardom of a dancer Victoria Page (Moira Shearer) who falls under the strict control of one charismatic, but elusive and mysterious company director Boris Lermontov (Anton Walbrook). Page becomes truly famous after appearing in Lermontov’s ballet “The Red Shoes”, but soon finds herself torn between her new love – composer of “The Red Shoes” – Julian Craster (Marius Goring) and her professional life. The film is brilliant in terms of cinematography, camera-movements and visual impact. The beautifully-designed production and the ballet, that incorporates a story of one girl whose red shoes take control over her life, are memorable. The film also makes certain observations on the creative process of a theatre/ballet production, and on art and artistic input. It asks – what price a person will be willing to pay for the sake of artistic glory and full professional realisation in theatre/ballet? The story of one girl whose red shoes control her (a Hans Christian Andersen fairy-tale) mirrors the story of Victoria Page who, ultimately, has to choose between her romantic interest and her blind devotion to the demands of the man behind the “The Red Shoes” genius – Boris Lermontov. 

This great film was directed by Michael Powell and Emeric Pressburger, who also directed Black Narcissus below, and what probably distinguishes these two films and what these two films have in common are breath-taking cinematography/visuals, but also, unfortunately, – a relatively “weak” and odd narrative content. The cinematographer of both films was a pioneer in film photography Jack Cardiff (The African Queen (1951)), but the stories in both films still come across as rather “thin”, with some rather inconsequential scenes and elements.  

west side storyII. West Side Story [1961] – ★★★★★

This film-musical is currently being remade by Steven Spielberg, to be released this year. West Side Story was adapted from the Broadway musical of the same name, taking the story of Shakespeare’s Romeo & Juliet as its basis, and sets it in one area of New York City in the 1950s where two opposing gangs battle for territory – the Sharks (a Puerto-Rican community) and the Jets. Lovely Natalie Wood plays Maria, a Puerto Rican girl, a daughter of strict parents and a loving sister to the leader of the Sharks – Bernardo. In spite of their different backgrounds, Maria falls in love with Tony, whose best friend Riff is the leader of the Jets. Will the love between these two end the rivalry between the two street gangs or lead to more tragedies? The exquisite choreography and musical numbers in West Side Story will steal any heart, and this film-musical also has brains since it deals thought-provokingly with the issue of immigrants’ lives in New York, as well as more than hints at police bias and the underlying causes of youth delinquency.  

Perhaps the modern audience nowadays will simply not have the required patience for the length of West Side Story, and it may also be true that some directional choices can be questioned, including that first meeting between Maria and Tony and the ending. Also, some actors look too old to play street teenagers, and it is unclear whether some moments in the film really have the appropriate and intended effect. However, in essence, West Side Story is still this timeless film with many beautiful, fun, and tense moments (the darkness of the latter descends rather unexpectedly in the plot). Even minor characters in this story have their deserved spotlight, the cast is inspirational, the music by Leonard Bernstein – memorable, and the whole film puts an interesting spin on the best-known love story we know. 

black narcissues posterIII. Black Narcissus [1947] – ★★★★1/2

In this film, which is based on a book by Rumer Godden, a group of Anglican nuns establishes a convent deep in the mountains of the Himalayas. They are led by one inexperienced Sister Superior Clodagh (Deborah Kerr) and have to get used to a new climate and way of life. When on the scene comes aloof, but obliging Mr Dean (David Farrar), one nun in particular – troublesome Ruth (Kathleen Byron) – sets her heart on getting romantically involved with him, leaving behind her religious vows. Other nuns also experience memory flashes and cannot account for their strange feelings in the new place. Moreover, such eccentric personalities as the Young General and Angu Ayah begin to add something unusual and exciting to the convent’s life. One thing is clear about Black Narcissus – it has some of the most splendid production designs and cinematography ever. There is some underlying humour in this picture, and the arising intriguing sexual tension between the characters is a curiosity all in itself. The character study of Sister Clodagh is fascinating, even if unfinished, and the atmospheric setting and the vivid images that the film puts a stress on, such as the bell tower, will probably stay with the viewers for a very long time.

However, when it comes to the story itself, it is soon evident that Black Narcissus is not a perfect film. The story presented is too unfocused. It is very difficult to guess where the script tries to place its main drama, and, even though it has odd elements that work delightfully together (and would not probably work in any other movie), the film also has many somewhat needless characters, as well as narrative threads and romance that go nowhere. Maybe Black Narcissus is too nuanced and much must be read into in every scene, but some plot-lines do end abruptly only for others to begin, and there are plenty of scenes that should probably have been cut because they do not add anything to the story. Perhaps one explanation for this is that this British film wanted to be as realistic as possible – and this is simply how the events would have unfolded in real life. The main action comes in the last ten or so minutes of the film, but, if it was really the main drama of Black Narcissus – then the film is rather strange. 


13 Comments Add yours

  1. mistermuse says:

    I recently bought and read an extremely interesting book titled THE FILMS OF MICHAEL POWELL AND THE ARCHERS by Scott Salwolke. The Archers were a collaboration of Powell and Emeric Pressburger, and the book includes a filmography of all their films, of which I’ve seen perhaps a half dozen and have yet to be disappointed. Highly recommended.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. dbmoviesblog says:

      Thanks very much for this recommendation. I will surely try to track this book down.

      Liked by 1 person

    2. dbmoviesblog says:

      I now wonder whether this book will shed some light on the philosophy behind Powell and Pressburger’s “virtually non-existent stories” in their films. I think what we have with The Red Shoes and Black Narcissus are films composed of some episodes woven together and the lack of one convincing drama. Only the final ten minutes of both films have the action scenes we patiently awaited and even they are strange to watch because the audience did not build the required emotion throughout to really care for the ending.

      Perhaps I have not seen enough British films in my lifetime, but I really wonder whether there is a method and inner logic in all this “madness” of the Archers because they do shoot their arrows in a strange fashion 🙂


  2. Paul S says:

    When I first watched The Red Shoes as a child I was spellbound, by the beautiful colour combinations, costumes, the art form of the ballet, the story, the movie as a whole. At the time I didn’t even realise it was an old movie.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. dbmoviesblog says:

      I can imagine how you must have felt as a child – It is an entrancing, spellbinding film. I think when it comes to films of that calibre it really does not matter when they were made.

      Liked by 1 person

  3. ManInBlack says:

    “America” from “West Side Story” is one of my favourite songs of all time thus one of my fave musical routines in film, alongside the Barn Dance showdown in “Seven Brides…” 😀

    Liked by 2 people

    1. dbmoviesblog says:

      “America” is also my favourite song from the whole musical! 🙂

      Liked by 2 people

  4. Arti says:

    I agree with you about West Side Story, itself a wonderful achievement at the time, and Bernstein’s music is incomparable. As you’ve noted, it just may be a bit dated now for modern audience. I’m sure that’s why Steven Spielberg thinks it’s time to make a contemporary version of it. I wish him well and all the cast of his upcoming movie.

    Liked by 1 person

  5. Tom says:

    I love the way you summarize West Side Story man. That’s excellent stuff. (Would comment on the others but I haven’t seen them lol)

    Liked by 1 person

  6. linnetmoss says:

    I really want to see The Red Shoes now! As to West Side Story, I am looking forward to the new film. I saw the new Broadway version directed by Ivo Van Hove and greatly enjoyed it. The story is very applicable to our own times and the music is eternal.

    Liked by 1 person

  7. Carson Maitland - Smith says:

    I’ll recommend the West Side Story once it’s out 💜

    Liked by 1 person

  8. ospreyshire says:

    I’ve seen West Side Story a while ago. I wasn’t aware it was going to be remade. The original could certainly be updated in different ways, so I could see that working with the right people.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.