“Hacksaw Ridge” Review

hacksaw0001Hacksaw Ridge [2016] – ★★★★1/2

An inspiring story about an unconventional hero? A graphic tale of the brutality of a war? A touching and believable love story? Mel Gibson can do it all, and brilliantly. His latest film Hacksaw Ridge tells the true story of Desmond Doss (Andrew Garfield), a kind, deeply-religious young man who also happens to be a conscientious objector, enlisting to serve in an army, while having a deep conviction against the commission of violence/murder and would not even touch a gun. Nominated for six Academy Awards, including Best Picture, Best Actor and Best Director, Hacksaw Ridge is that kind of a film which one can easily define as “great”: a moving, heart-felt story is matched by a dedicated director and a committed actor who do their work exceptionally well.


Hacksaw Ridge starts off with Desmond’s difficult childhood spent with his often drunk and violent father (Hugo Weaving), a retired army official, his troubled mother (Rachel Griffiths) and brother Hal. Here, we see the first instances of Desmond’s psychological trauma when he nearly kills his brother by accident with a brick while play-fighting. Later, when he is older, he sees his mother violently abused by his father, and there is also an incident involving a gun. All these situations play a major part of Desmond’s conscientious objection and his aversion to firearms. Moreover, from his childhood, Desmond is very religious, and the Bible commandment: “Thou shalt not kill” means much to him. All this is vividly and powerfully presented, and we really get the feeling that Desmond vows to be the complete opposite of his violent father.

Some years later, church-going Desmond has aspirations to become a doctor, and meets a pretty girl Dorothy (Teresa Palmer) while being in a hospital after just helping to save a young man injured on the street. Desmond and Dorothy fall in love, and Desmond also enlists to serve in the army as a “conscientious objector” without the possibility to bear arms, because he is morally against murder. In the army, Desmond battles with stigma, discrimination against him (he is called a “coward”), and has to confront brutal trainings and random beatings. After a fierce court battle, he is eventually allowed to proceed to a battleground without a weapon to defend himself. Then, at the Battle of Okinawa, Private Doss, single-handedly, saves the lives of more or less 70 people: tending to the wounded, providing assistance and taking the wounded away from danger, when most of the remaining men who survived the initial attack leave. For his exemplary bravery, Desmond Doss is later awarded the Medal of Honour for service above and beyond the call of duty.

The most amazing aspect of this film is that this is not just another film about the WWII. This is a film about a conscientious objector or a “conscientious co-operator”, as Desmond liked to call himself. Thus, it is very interesting to see how Desmond’s religious and moral views play out in a real war situation, and, on that basis, this film will also be enjoyed by people who are not normally into war films. The first part (hour) of the film is different from the second part (hour), but this is because it shows the pre-war and war-scenarios respectively.

hacksaw ridge

One of the most impressive things about Gibson’s Hacksaw Ridge is how well the story is told. Not one scene is needless or feeling out-of-place. The film never “waffles”, and every scene tries to communicate something important. In this film, and taking into account Braveheart (1995), Gibson demonstrates that he is one of the masters of presenting deeply-emotional and moving hero portrayals. The soundtrack, sometimes reminding too much of that found in Braveheart, helps things along, but the powerful dialogue is the most important contributing factor to this success. At times it is meaningful, for example, when Desmond is told that “a gun is every soldier’s lover”, “concubine”, perhaps, “the only thing in life a soldier would truly love”; at other times it is darkly funny, for example when someone remarks close to the battlefield that “you are not in Kansas anymore, Dorothy”.

Also, in a war-themed or even a just biographical film like this, the “romance” side of a film is either ignored, underdeveloped or badly-presented. Surprisingly, the Hacksaw Ridge screenwriters and the director manage to present quiet a love story here. The chemistry between Desmond (Garfield) and Dorothy (Palmer) is electrifying; their onscreen attraction feels very real; and the scenes where Desmond and Dorothy are together remind of those epic scenes of pure romantic atmosphere present in Gibson’s Braveheart. The scene where Desmond first sees Dorothy in hospital is magical; brilliantly presented; and such phrases between them as: “I fell in love with you because you were not like anyone else”, make their romance even more touching.

It is impossible not to fall in love (well, more so if you are a girl, maybe) with Andrew Garfield’s portrayal of Desmond Doss. His Desmond is likeable, but in a quiet manner. Garfield shows the kindness and goodness of Desmond, and we instinctively root for him and wish him well. His simplicity and inexperience in medicine and dating clearly show, but he still appears good-humoured and optimistic. Be it under a safe harbour of his local church or in a battlefield, Desmond never loses his essence, his anti-firearm conviction or his devotion to a noble cause. At one point Desmond says: “I don’t know what I am going to do with myself if I don’t stay true to what I believe”, and also “I am not going to pretend to be something that I am not; I am what I am.” In that way, Garfield’s portrayal of Desmond is a powerful one, and he gives the performance of his career. As for the cast in general, Gibson had to cast largely Australian actors to secure a government funding from Australia. This explains so many Australian actors in the film, for example, Hugo Weaving (V for Vendetta (2005)) who impresses as Desmond’s deranged father.

Hacksaw Ridge has been accused of jingoism, and the Japanese are really not presented in the film in the best of lights. However, this criticism is a bit unfair. Gibson is the director well-versed in directing very patriotic (Braveheart) and religiously-zealous (The Passion of the Christ (2004)) films, and, compared to his previous films, Hacksaw Ridge is not particularly extreme or distorted in its “patriotism”. That maybe because we get to know Desmond Doss so personally, and we largely see the events from his point of view.

hacksaw ridge

Hacksaw Ridge has also been attacked for its portrayal of extreme graphic violence, which some view as simply realistic, while others think was quite unnecessary. It is true that there are many scenes in this film which some viewers would find hard to stomach, but they should be seen in the context, taking into account the main purpose of the film. The graphic violence in the film may be what is necessary here for an effective juxtaposition and dramatisation. Given that there is this tender, kind hero with high morals who would never touch a gun, there must be shown some extreme, totally godless, brutality on the battlefield to draw an effective contrast. In that way, Desmond is like a saint in a true hell, and a true hell on a battlefield Gibson surely delivers.

The real notable weakness in this film is the ending. There is a nice, touching documentary footage shown of the real Desmond Doss, as he recalls one of his war episodes, but there is nothing shown about the future fate of our film hero. The film started off with Desmond’s childhood and his difficult relationship with his father, allocating a fair amount of time to the development of his relationship with his sweetheart Dorothy, and, yet, at the end, we see no evident conclusion or a “happy ending” involving his family or his wife. The film feels incomplete without at least showing some references to it, since it focused so much on these private sides of Desmond’s life at the beginning.

To conclude, Hacksaw Ridge is exceptional in many ways, being unbelievably moving. For a film about a conscientious objector, this film may be viewed as unjustly violent, but Gibson still presents his hero in the best possible light, and the love story electrifies the screen. 


11 Comments Add yours

  1. Lloyd Marken says:

    You certainly seem moved by it mate.


    1. dbmoviesblog says:

      I don’t see how anyone would not be 🙂

      Liked by 1 person

  2. I agree with the criticisms of the film regarding the representation of the Japanese and the use of graphic violence. The latter overwhelms the official plot about a conscientious objector. And Gibson has form on this, witness ‘The Passion of the Christ’.
    Also the film is not strictly realistic. The ‘ridge’ in the film appears to be four times the height of the actual ridge in Okinawa.


    1. dbmoviesblog says:

      Thanks for your comments. I think the film is as realistic as any film can get. For decades Doss refused filmmakers to make his story into a movie because he was afraid of an unrealistic portrayal. Even Doss’s son agreed that Gibson’s film was a realistic presentation of his dad’s journey. I think the actual height of the ridge is so irrelevant.


  3. I enjoyed the movie as well. Okinawa was an incredibly violent campaign, since for the first time the Japanese were defending what they considered to be Japanese soil, so the portrayal wasn’t excessive. While I understand the screenwriter and director have to focus the story, the movie actually lessens Doss’s heroism, since Okinawa wasn’t his first campaign in the war. Also, he was one of the men who actually hung the nets used to climb the ridge. Sadly, Doss didn’t have a happy ending, as his wounds from the war left him disabled. But I was glad this movie gave him his due after he was pretty much forgotten.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. dbmoviesblog says:

      Thanks, I didn’t even know these details. Interesting. There should be more films like this one to bring attention to such heroic people. There is something special about true heroes who are quiet and not boastful and it is so easy to forget what they have done and sacrificed for other people. Next, I want to see a movie done about Rosa Parks who refused to give up her seat on a bus to a white passenger, or someone similar. In that way, I also like Doss’s story because it is also through his quiet determination and strength he achieved so much – fighting against the initial discrimination and ridicule of others. Most people do not immediately see all the bravery that is inside these people, and they end up being more heroic than most visibly confident loud-mouths on the street.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.